No, Universal Affirmatives Can Only Be Partially Converted

Black kid, pointing to a Hasidic Jewish man: Yo, check out the Amish dude!
Mother: He ain’t Amish, they wear straw hats.
Black kid: But he’s got a beard. Amish guys got beards. So he’s Amish.

–Uptown 4 train

Overheard by: jewish girl