Skip to content
  • Submit a Quote!
  • Browse
    • Browse by week
    • Browse by month
    • Categories
  • Link & Subscribe
    • Link to us
    • Best of via e-mail
    • Submit a banner
    • Icons
  • About
    • Top Spies
    • Contributors
    • Editors
    • Contact
    • Hatemail
    • Letters from Canadia
    • About
    • Privacy
  • Buy
    • Buy the NY book
    • Buy the Office book
    • Buy the t-shirt

When “How Many Candy Corns Are in the Jar?” Stops Being a Fun Party Game

Guy: How many dicks can you fit in your vagina?
Girl: Umm, I'd say five.

–Fire Island

Overheard by: Pranav

  • Posted on March 5, 2016
  • Default, Girls, Guys, Long Island, Penis, Questions, Sex, Vagina
PrevPreviousBarbie Dolls Get More and More Lifelike Every Year
NextWhite Folks Hire People to Kill Each OtherNext
© 2025 OverheardinNewYork.com
  • Ketubahs & Gay Ketubahs
  • Privacy Policy, Terms & Conditions
  • Resources
Hat Tip 🎩 to The Marketing Scientist